The fiasco of the proposal to reinstate Article 370


- Decisions reminiscent of the Ram Mandir judgment

- Occasional

- The Supreme Court has won the hearts of the people and increased confidence in India's judicial system

- Chief Justice D. Y. Chandrachud

One date was 9-11-2019 and the other is 11-12-2023. Both dates are associated with important judgments. Both times precautionary measures were taken for the safety of the country and both the verdicts won the self-respect of the country.

A total of 23 people filed a petition citing various reasons such as the removal of Article 370 by the central government is an inappropriate step. Known faces who filed the petition include Sitaram Yechury, Tehsin Poonawalla, etc. The petitioners fielded an army of eminent lawyers, including Kapil Sibal, Gopal Subramaniam and others. Kapil Sibal frequently gave updates on the case to the news media. After a long hearing, Supreme Court Chief Justice D. Y. A five-judge bench headed by Chandrachud unanimously held that the removal of Article 370 from Jammu and Kashmir was a right and just step.

Similar excitement was seen during the judgment of Ram Mandir on 8-11-2019. At that time, Chandrachud was also on the bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogai. He said that the temple was demolished and a mosque was built on it. Therefore, the demand of the Ram Mandir Committee to allow the temple to be built again on that land is justified.

There were also those who said that if Article 370 is removed, blood will be shed in the country, but the Modi government showed courage and removed the article. To everyone's surprise, there was not even a normal gravel storm.

Kapil Sibal, who called Article 370 illegal, said in an interview before the verdict that some wars are fought only to be lost. Kapil Sibal left the Congress party in 2022 after not getting a Rajya Sabha ticket and ran as an independent with the support of the Samajwadi Party. Kapil Sibal's father was a noted advocate. His two sons also practice in the Supreme Court.

It has become clear that the case against the removal of Article 370 was unnecessary. Some people fight such cases for the sake of publicity to attract public attention and create sympathy for a particular class.

We have a section challenging the decisions of the central government and the judgments of the judiciary. Such a class has the backing of some political parties. For example, some prominent people like Prashant Bhushan opened the court at midnight in 2015 to stay the execution of Yakub Memon, the culprit in the 1993 Mumbai blasts case that claimed 257 lives and moved to commute the sentence. The court rejected the new plea at 4.10 am on July 30 and kept the death sentence intact. A few hours later Yakub was hanged.

Such a judgment shows that anyone in India is allowed to raise objections and can resort to judicial courts. In both the Ram Mandir and Article 370 cases, the petitioners were given ample opportunity to present themselves.

There are frequent reports of a cold war going on between the central government and the Supreme Court judges. Central government keeps taking tough decisions. People who are upset with it can knock the doors of the court. When it comes to the sovereignty of the country, everyone follows some law and constitution.

There are many cases in India in which the government and the Supreme Court have been put to the test. Today again by upholding the Constitution, the Supreme Court has won the hearts of the people and increased confidence in the judicial system of India.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The specter of Bhopal gas scandal resurfaced, demand to take action in America too

Image
- Strict demand of 12 members of the US Congress - Occasional - The accident will complete 40 years in December but no action has been taken against the company The entire India remembers the Gozaro Day of 2-3 December 1984 when thousands of people died in their sleep due to the toxic gas leaked from the Union Carbide Company in Bhopal. Thousands of people came under the effect of this poisonous gas. Many attempts were made to cover up the incident. 12 members of the US Congress have written to the Department of Justice on September 12 to issue a summons on Dow Chemicals to take action against the company which is considered responsible. Despite repeated summonses by the Indian court, the company authorities do not appear. Union Carbide's current owner is Dow Chemicals. MPs who wrote to the US Department of Justice wrote that under the Mutual Legal Assistance Agreement, a notice could be issued to the Dow company on criminal matters. The owner of the company in the Bhopal gas ...
Read more

The Endless War of the Jews.

Image
The conflict between Israel and Palestine has started again. So this work is to freshen old wounds. Both are facing each other in modern times, but the reality is that this war is very ancient. In fact, this is the time when conflict between the two countries occurs every year. In the month of Ramadan, the people of Palestine raise the voice of their freedom. While in the same period of time, Israel celebrates its independence. For the past few days, a new conflict has started between Israel and Palestine. The Israeli offensive, known as the Battle of Gaza, has proved devastating for the Palestinian people. The conflict between Palestinian protesters and Israeli police has been going on for a long time. It continues forever in the ancient city of Jerusalem, where Muslim, Jewish and Christian holy sites are located. This time the conflict took place at the beginning of the month of Ramadan, when the people of Palestine strengthened their demand to prove their existence to the world an...
Read more

The language is full of love, full of repulsion

Image
- Unencumbered joy-inexhaustible antani Bhasha bhaghe ki Bhur, Ranman Jite e Shur... but uncle turns around and says, bhasha bhaghe ki Bhur in 'P-Ran' ​​Jite e Shur... In short, uncle calls the one who wins not in the battlefield but in the P-Barnfield as brave. Ranveer who shows valor in the desert and the bridegroom shows valor is the Ranveer... The British went and put English. Kaka's birth also took place before independence, so he did not come out of the shadow of English. Garvi, a mixture of English and Gujarati, blabbers Pathukaka in Gujreji and says back to me that I know the mother tongue and know the other tongue too, so I have fun using Gujreji. On Saturday morning, uncle left with a small tub of oil. I asked my uncle, 'Where are you going?' Uncle replied, 'As it is Saturday, I am going to do oiling at Rokdia Hanuman temple.' I chuckled and said, 'Instead of saying I am going to do oiling at the Hanuman temple, I should directly say that I...
Read more

Delhi talk: Priyanka's son Rehan will enter politics?

Image
New Delhi: As his nephew Rehan also joined Rahul Gandhi's Bharat Jodo Yatra in Madhya Pradesh, speculations have started that Rehan will enter politics. Priyanka Gandhi's son Rehan is a wildlife photographer and is not in lime light. Now suddenly for several days he is walking with Rahul on the journey. When Priyanka joined this journey for the first time, her husband Robert Vadra and son Rehan also joined. Priyanka and Vadra then leave but Rehan is still on the journey. Like Rahul, Rehan greets people and takes pictures with people, so it is expected that he too will enter politics. The Congress leader does not deny these speculations. Since Rahul Gandhi is not married, he believes that Rehan will come forward to preserve the political legacy of the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty. However, Congress spokesperson Jairam Ramesh said that there is no need to look at this through the lens of politics. Rahul Gandhi has been away from his family for some time so the family came to meet him....
Read more

If the women's reservation bill is passed, but when will it be implemented is a big question

Image
- The government is silent on how the bottlenecks in implementation will be removed - Under the one person, one vote rule, seats in southern and western states will decrease while seats in northern states will increase - Finally the delimitation exercise started in 2002 and it ended after 6 years i.e. on 19 February 2008. Thus, according to the sequence, the first census will be conducted after 2026 - Opinion - P. Chidambaram Let's look at three important dates in the history of India's Constitution and Parliament: September 12, 1996: Prime Minister Dev Gowda's government presented the Constitution (81 Amendment) Bill in Parliament. In this bill, there was a provision to reserve one-third seats for women in Parliament and state legislatures. However, no further progress could be made. March 9, 2020: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's government presented the Constitution (108th Amendment) Bill in the Rajya Sabha. This bill was similar to the 1996 bill and was passed...
Read more

The problem of educational quality.

Image
The admission work of non-medical colleges has been completed. The Gujarat University Syndicate has announced the decision to convert some three-year courses into four-year courses, so there is no change in the quality of studies. The problem of the method of imparting education is more than education. Our educational system has acquired a knack for brutally infantilizing the childhood of the child, the innate instincts of the youth and the natural creativity of any human being. The word immediately after education in the dictionary is pedagogy. We have known for centuries that education is an art, but the fact is that the art has become obsolete. Be it online education or classroom heaven, the great Indian teachers of this era have been caught in the act of instilling the interest that makes students engrossed in studies, which the new generation is reaping the brunt of. Education has always been neglected even though radical change is not only necessary, but also inevitable. The ND...
Read more

Talking about Delhi: The team for Sangh-BJP coordination will change

Image
New Delhi: A meeting of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh's All India Representative Sabha, which began in Haryana, has requested to send some campaigners to the BJP before the Lok Sabha elections. BJP National President J.P. Nadda personally Dr. the head of the union. Mohan Bhagwat has requested this. Sources claim that a decision will be taken on the last day of the meeting in Panipat Samalkha, which will last till March 14. Some of the faces working for an alliance between the Sangh and the BJP may also change. A decision will also be taken in this meeting to change the responsibility of some Sangh volunteers and send them to BJP. As this is the last big meeting of Sanghan stalwarts before the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, many big decisions will be taken about helping the BJP in the elections. 2025 will complete 100 years of the establishment of the Union. A special discussion regarding the centenary year is to be held in the meeting of the Sangh representative assembly. The discu...
Read more

The brewing rift between Bhutan and China will aggravate the Doklam dispute

Image
- World Window - Bhutan-China do not have diplomatic relations, yet visiting China's foreign minister threatened India's interests by hinting at resolving the Doklam dispute. Bhutan. Nestled in the lap of the Himalayas is a lovely little country that is said to be the last 'Shangri La' of the world. Shangri-La is a place where everything is perfect. The fresh cool air, the snow-capped mountain peaks, the green valleys, the clear-white sky and the dark blue sheets of the rivers flowing low with its reflection... As if nature has not created this place with care for each and every thing! It is said that the citizens of Bhutan are the happiest in the world. The world adopted the idea of ​​happiness index much later, in Bhutan since 1972 the method of assessing well-being based on the growth happiness index has been in operation. It is the responsibility of the government departments to ensure that problems are minimized, chaos is minimized and the happiness of the peop...
Read more

The return of Corona.

Image
The numbers are increasing every day. The government has not yet mandated the wearing of masks. The pandemic turned the professional world completely hostile. That is why the number of suicide cases increased by thirty percent in 2020 and 2021 compared to 2019. No survey can explain this increase, but it is obvious that the main reason for the increase in the rate of suicide is the financial crisis and Corona has made everyone helpless in that crisis. Only if there is universal sympathy in the society, the confusion can be solved. During the last lockdown, the government did not succeed as per the expected help announcements. Help could not reach many people. Although suicidal steps cannot be justified by any means, people who have reached a stressful state of mind do not see any ray of hope. They do not even get help from the government or any other means. Financial viability is the first requirement. The backbone of India's business sector is made up of medium and small scale m...
Read more